Page 2 of 2

Re: Quest bug daggerfallunity_windows_x64-62

Posted: Sun Dec 09, 2018 5:43 pm
by pango
I haven't seen any teleporters in that dungeon...

Re: Quest bug daggerfallunity_windows_x64-62

Posted: Sun Dec 09, 2018 9:46 pm
by jayhova
Hazelnut wrote: Sun Dec 09, 2018 4:56 pm Did you check for teleporters?
I'm also pretty sure none exist.

Re: No path between dungeon blocks - cheat required to complete [GAME-DATA RELATED]

Posted: Sun Dec 09, 2018 11:02 pm
by Interkarma
I can confirm the following:
  • Dungeon Wayrest\The Hold of Ashford has only two interior blocks - Wx18 (0,0) and Nx57 (1,0). This places blocks in an east-west configuration relative to each other.
  • There are the usual geomorph links between these blocks from either side, but links on both sides terminate with a dead-end in the block interior. There is no traversal route between them I can see.
  • There are no teleporters in the game data for these blocks - which wouldn't help much anyway as teleporters only transfer player around within the same block. The problem is traversing blocks from east to west.
  • This dungeon is essentially non-viable in an east-west configuration. Either block would be fine if adjacent to a different block, or in a larger dungeon with more routes, or even if these blocks were placed in a different config such as north-south. They might even be fine with blocks swapped around.
We all know Daggerfall's dungeon design has some impossible configurations, and this is unfortunately one of them. If we can start curating a list dungeons with invalid configurations, it might be possible to come up with some general solution for them down the road. At the moment, this is just one of the many little errors inherited from the game data.

Re: No path between dungeon blocks - cheat required to complete [GAME-DATA RELATED]

Posted: Mon Dec 10, 2018 3:11 am
by jayhova
Interkarma wrote: Sun Dec 09, 2018 11:02 pm I can confirm the following:
  • Dungeon Wayrest\The Hold of Ashford has only two interior blocks - Wx18 (0,0) and Nx57 (1,0). This places blocks in an east-west configuration relative to each other.
  • There are the usual geomorph links between these blocks from either side, but links on both sides terminate with a dead-end in the block interior. There is no traversal route between them I can see.
  • There are no teleporters in the game data for these blocks - which wouldn't help much anyway as teleporters only transfer player around within the same block. The problem is traversing blocks from east to west.
  • This dungeon is essentially non-viable in an east-west configuration. Either block would be fine if adjacent to a different block, or in a larger dungeon with more routes, or even if these blocks were placed in a different config such as north-south. They might even be fine with blocks swapped around.
We all know Daggerfall's dungeon design has some impossible configurations, and this is unfortunately one of them. If we can start curating a list dungeons with invalid configurations, it might be possible to come up with some general solution for them down the road. At the moment, this is just one of the many little errors inherited from the game data.
So I get credit for this right? There is a scoreboard where we get points for discovering bugs, correct?

So I'm gonna say what I said the day I started playing Daggerfall right after it came out. Bring back Passwall.